Do Canva Resume Templates Beat the Bots?

We put Canva to the test and reviewed each resume template sample for the most common formatting errors found in ATS!

The results were… disappointing.

We have a little bit of personal experience with these forms as well, as Brianna-Lynn’s infamous pink resume that didn’t beat the bots was a Canva template!

The Pros:

  1. If you were a p@ndemic-era student and did any online classes, you probably got to know Canva very closely. It’s free and easy to use.

  2. It gives GREAT examples of what a resume or CV could look like! Some are very cute. We love that.

The Cons:

  1. We were shocked, but NONE of the templates are optimized for ATS! None of them would Beat the Bots and make it to human eyes... Unless your company was one of the 1% or so that doesn’t use that software, or requires you to manually input all of your information into their own system box-by-box.

  2. It gives bad advice and sets you up for failure! For reasons we discuss in our resume guide, for example, you should NEVER include your home address. Similarly, including your date of High School graduation can introduce subconscious human bias against your application.

  3. Let’s just count the formatting errors we see in a couple sample templates to give you a better idea of how bad these are…

In the “Samira Hadid” sample template from Canva, we see that it has multiple columns, a “bars” rating system, a photo, some unusual fonts, some interesting visual items like horizontal dividers, and section headers like “Work Experience” are overlaid on an image. Many ATS will (maybe) read her name, and the left-most column at most, and those are just the most obvious issues. It is unlikely to provide a comprehensible plain text summary to the hiring manager at all, and if it does, it will be jumbled and miss almost every keyword. Samira would almost definitely not get the job.

Let’s take a look at one more.

In the “Powell Finwood” sample template from Canva, it doesn’t have much personality, but still manages to pack a ton of fatal flaws as far as ATS is concerned. Powell has a header, which means that some ATS will actually read that as the end of the page. Yes. The hiring manager will simply get his name, and that’s it. Straight to the trash. We don’t love that for him. There are more errors on this than we can count on our fingers, but we think you get the point now. ATS is awful, and hard to beat.

So, is Canva a total no-go? Actually, no!

We love Canva’s free designs… if they’re used right. We highly recommend using an ATS-optimized resume template to get your foot in the door with your online application, but if you really want to wow your interviewers or convey some of your personality, Canva templates are totally acceptable and can be aesthetic.

But wait! Does EVERYONE actually need an ATS-optimized resume?

Actually, this is very industry-dependent! Are you in the tech industry? One of our friends just tweets at people he wants to work for, and that works for him. Are you a recent graduate in healthcare? Your school may have programs to set you up with an employer, and you may be submitting your resume directly to a real person in HR who is already expecting your specific application. Some very small businesses or non-profits may also accept applications directly to a real human. It just depends. If you are applying to customer service positions, you may just need to insert your qualifications directly into their proprietary system’s text boxes, bypassing common ATS software that most companies in regular blue- or white-collar industries use.

If you’ve sent out more than a dozen applications and not heard back, though, ATS is most likely to blame.

Some Quick Interview Tips

As we discuss in our interview guide, printing out a few copies of your resume to bring in to the interview (especially if you are interviewing with a panel of people!) gives you the ability to not only keep on track of your talking points by having your own resume on hand, but also allows interviewers to ask more in-depth questions about specific experiences you have listed. Plus, it makes you look very professional and prepared.

We like to print a couple copies and keep them in a professional looking binder, along with a notepad to write down questions we may think of during the interview (so we don’t interrupt and don’t forget to ask) as well as a list of pre-prepared questions for the interviewer(s). Don’t forget a pen!

Being confident and prepared can really help alleviate some of the interview anxiety that nearly everyone experiences.

Previous
Previous

We Put Resumake.io to the Test

Next
Next

Hiring Practices Hide Talent